Here is another great makeup face off — NYC Bronzer Vs elf Bronzer. These two bronzer products are in almost every list of makeup dupes. In this article, we will compare these 2 best drugstore bronzer finds. We will give a lowdown on why and how each of these makeup faves can be the best bronzer for you.
NYC Bronzer vs e.l.f. Bronzer | A Drugstore Makeup Battle
The NYC bronzer in Sunny is the most reviewed bronzer at Tanning Lotion. Already pitted against NYX Matte Bronzer, this flagship product is from U.S. brand New York Color. It has long been a proven brand for its makeup in the colors coveted by every beauty junkie.
e.l.f., on the other hand, is an acronym for Eyes Lips Face, (e.l.f.) Cosmetics, a global makeup brand based also in New York. It is hugely popular among cash-strapped makeup addicts for its dollar-friendly makeup. e.l.f. also offers skincare products and beauty tools, of which some are popular as well.
2. Key Features
As mentioned in our previous reviews, the NYC Smooth Skin Bronzing Powder in Sunny is beloved for its iconic brown packaging and the distinct NYC logo. Aside from the built-in mirror and makeup sponge, there is a transparent panel where you can view the bronzer’s signature color. The e.l.f. 4-in-1 bronzer comes in a simple, rectangular black case with a mirror inside. The pressed powder is divided into four colors that can be blended together with a blush or contour brush.
Both are in pressed powder form, so you can use a makeup sponge, blush, or contour brush to pick up the product. In terms of pigmentation, e.l.f. is the better drugstore bronzer for dark skin and the best drugstore bronzer for contouring, according to one fan. The pigmentation of the NYC bronzer, on the other hand, is enough for fair-skinned people looking to get a bit of matte glow on their face and collarbones.
4. Value for Money
The NYC bronzer seems to be the better bronzer when it comes to pricing (USD2.99 plus shipping for 0.33 ounce of product). Though, the 4-in-1 e.l.f. bronzer palette is a real deal at USD4, too. You can choose to use one, or combine two to four colors in the bronzer palette to highlight or contour your face. The e.l.f. 4-1 bronzer has three palette variants (Warm/Cool/Golden), each specially made to cater across all skin types.
5. Customer Rating
Beauty addicts rely on the NYC bronzer as the best bronzer because of its matte finish. This matte finish makes the contour more natural-looking. Tanning aficionados may go with the e.l.f. 4-1 bronzer because of its shimmer properties. The shimmer in the bronzer can help emphasize the golden tan, similar to what a liquid bronzer can offer.
Still confused which one to get? We have listed the reasons to convince you of one choice:
- Best for people with fair skin
- Matte application
- Comes in 3 palette variants at 4 colors each
- Best for people with medium to dark-skinned
- Lasts longer
It is always best to learn what a bronzer product’s weakness is. While they do not sound major, they might be a big deal for some or you.
- The color may be “orangey” for some people
- Because there is only one color, you cannot experiment that much.
- Does not come with its own applicator
- Some of the colors may not work well for everyone.
Check out this NYC Bronzer vs e.l.f. Bronzer review by nataliabow below:
With quality outcome at reasonable price points, these drugstore bronzers can definitely stand up against their high-priced competitors. It is up to you to choose your match. Or, you can choose to use both depending on your mood’s liking.
Do you prefer the NYC bronzer or the e.l.f. Bronzer? Let us know in the comments section below!